Comparisons
Compare your heating + solar options in 2026
TL;DR
- 5 comparisons cover the main UK switching decisions in 2026.
- Every comparison uses 2026 UK numbers + the £7,500 BUS grant where applicable.
- Heat pump usually wins on day-one cost after BUS, regardless of current fuel.
- Running cost saving is biggest switching off LPG, smallest switching off mains gas.
- Brand and product-specific comparisons coming next — fuel-type first.
Pick the comparison that matches your home today
Each guide below answers the same five questions for one specific switch — how much it costs to install, what you pay after the £7,500 Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant, what running costs look like in 2026, how the carbon stacks up, and when the alternative still makes sense.
Most UK homes on mains gas
Heat pump vs gas boiler
Highest-volume UK comparison. £7,500 BUS grant maths against modern combi boiler running costs.
Read the comparison~1.1M UK homes on heating oil
Heat pump vs oil boiler
Off-gas-grid switching guide. Bigger running-cost saving than mains gas; tank-removal logistics covered.
Read the comparison~150k UK homes on LPG
Heat pump vs LPG boiler
Sharpest running-cost saving of the three fossil fuels. Tank-lease + supply-contract unwind under the 2018 CMA Order.
Read the comparison~500k UK homes on direct electric
Heat pump vs electric boiler
Same fuel (grid electricity), very different efficiency. Heat pump delivers 3.5× the heat per kWh; switching saves £600–£1,200/year on a typical UK home.
Read the comparison~700k UK homes on Economy 7
Heat pump vs night storage heaters
Storage heaters run on cheap Economy 7 overnight electricity but the heat is gone by evening. Heat pump on a time-of-use tariff matches the cost story + delivers heat on demand.
Read the comparisonChoosing your heat pump type
Air source vs ground source heat pump
Both qualify for the same £7,500 BUS grant; air-source suits 95% of UK homes. When ground source actually pays back.
Read the comparisonHybrid quote? Read this first
Hybrid vs full heat pump
BUS grant excludes hybrid installs since 2023. Full heat pump usually wins on cost, carbon, and complexity — narrow niche for hybrids remains.
Read the comparisonConsidering rooftop solar PV
Solar panels vs no solar
20-year cashflow on a 4 kW UK install. Payback in 7–11 years on most south-facing roofs. SEG tariff selection matters.
Read the comparisonSpec'ing your solar system
Solar + battery vs solar alone
Adding a 5–10 kWh battery costs £3,500–£6,500. Pays back in 9–13 years; faster (5–8) on smart tariffs or with heat pump / EV load.
Read the comparisonPicking a heat pump brand
Daikin vs Mitsubishi heat pump
Side-by-side spec comparison of Daikin Altherma and Mitsubishi Ecodan ranges in the UK. SCOP, sound, warranty, controls — published data only.
Read the comparisonPicking a heat pump brand
Vaillant vs Daikin heat pump
Vaillant aroTHERM plus runs R290 propane (lowest-GWP refrigerant); Daikin Altherma 3 R runs R32. Spec comparison from published UK product data.
Read the comparisonPicking a heat pump brand
Vaillant vs Mitsubishi heat pump
Top-3 UK brand comparison. R290 propane vs R32 refrigerant, sound-power gap (~3-4 dB(A) lower for Vaillant), installer-footprint differences.
Read the comparisonSpec'ing your heat pump install
Underfloor heating vs radiators (heat pumps)
Install-time decision: UFH (£6-£15k retrofit) vs upgraded radiators (£1.5-£5.5k). SCOP advantage to UFH but rarely pays back on running cost alone.
Read the comparisonSolar buyers considering both
Solar PV vs solar thermal
Electricity vs hot water. PV almost always wins on 2026 UK economics — RHI closed 2022, PV prices fell, heat pumps + PV pair natively. Niche thermal use cases remain.
Read the comparisonPicking a heat pump brand
Samsung vs LG heat pump
Korean-brand pair, typically 5–10% below Daikin / Mitsubishi pricing. R32 across both; LG has an R290 variant from late 2024.
Read the comparisonTuning your heat-pump running cost
Heat pump electricity tariffs UK 2026
Octopus Cosy vs British Gas Heat Pump Plus vs EDF GoElectric vs E.ON Next Heat Pump. £200–£400/yr saving vs standard variable.
Read the comparisonHeat pump type decision
Air-to-air vs air-to-water heat pump
Only air-to-water qualifies for the £7,500 BUS grant. Air-to-air is cheaper pre-grant but can't heat hot water — narrow niche only.
Read the comparisonBuying new vs upgrading existing
New build vs retrofit heat pump
Future Homes Standard 2025 made heat pumps standard in English new builds. Retrofit gets the £7,500 BUS grant; new build doesn't (it's mandatory).
Read the comparisonPaying for the heat pump
Heat pump finance options UK 2026
Five paths for the £1,500–£6,500 net cost after BUS: cash, 0% installer finance, green mortgage, secured loan, heat-pump-as-a-service.
Read the comparison
Not sure which one applies?
Start with what currently heats your home: mains gas (most urban UK homes), heating oil or LPG (rural off-gas-grid), or direct electric / storage heaters. If you’re considering solar PV separately from heating, the solar-vs-no-solar guide answers that on its own. The free pre-survey at propertoasty.com/check gives you the specific verdict for your property in 5 minutes.
What’s coming next
Brand-specific comparisons (Daikin vs Mitsubishi, Vaillant vs Samsung) and product-type comparisons (hybrid vs full heat pump, solar + battery vs solar alone) are next on the roadmap. We sequence fuel-type switches first because they cover the largest UK audience and the decision is more binary; brand comparisons matter once you’ve already decided to switch.
Sources
- GOV.UK — Boiler Upgrade Scheme — accessed May 2026
- Ofgem — Boiler Upgrade Scheme guidance — accessed May 2026
- Energy Saving Trust — Heating and energy — accessed May 2026